In the society as portrayed, some of the people who manage the database would be doing good business altering records. Especially since no one really believes in the system anyway. Once again, the movie does not think out its premise. After all, see what happened to Vincent after he was discovered. He was thrown into a prison and tortured until an angry mob broke in and lynched him from the tallest tree.
Oh, wait. No, he was punished by being able to achieve his one great ambition in life. That certainly will discourage people! He spends the entire movie being a very threatening figure in every interaction he has with Vincent. Why go out of your way to say these things? Yet they receive no punishment for what they do.
Yet no one is punished, and Vincent is rewarded. This is completely inconsistent with the premise of the film. You certainly have the right to like it. I prefer a movie that actually works out the science fictional premise with some rigor. Silly, silly movie. Just think of this:.
Society agrees that people like [main character] are inferior and not capable of doing certain jobs. All the smart people agree with this idea, based on some kind of genetic screening the details of which are not explained and not aimed at people who actually understand genetics.
But he succeeds anyway - becomes one of the best and brightest. So where does that leave everyone? Hmm, I guess we really fucked up with that whole genetic screening idea huh? See: the never-ending questions surrounding black quarterbacks. But in the span of 25 years short enough that all the people in charge must be in-valids , society has decided that discrimination by genetic code is A-OK.
I realized that about five minutes after I shut off the movie:. That was just as profound as my friends said it was! The world of Gattaca really is just a few years away! Soon, all the elderly politicians will pass laws that make in-valids illegal… wait a minute. Maybe longer. What do modern airline pilots wear? Cafe Society. I love Gattaca. Invalid, to me is a play on invalid, as in a sick or bedridden person.
The genes that turn people into product-liability lawyers had long been eliminated. You hire someone solely on the basis of his genetics? I think the implication was that the medical monitoring was far more rigorous than necessary, for screening purposes. To prevent exactly what the main character was doing. The main character was smart enough to pass everything but the genetic screening.
It was stated that the accident happened overseas and was not documented. Improved computer security. Racial profiling happens even now.
Astronauts going to Saturn in business suits? Of course not. Just think of this: Society agrees that people like [main character] are inferior and not capable of doing certain jobs. Essay Sample Check Writing Quality. Life in the movie Gattaca is outwardly orderly and efficient. Perfect genes are chosen for potential children, so the parents already know their child will be successful.
Seamless health and physical traits are valued, and those with these qualities are called Valids. Valids are able to work the high status jobs such as the jobs in the Aerospace Corporation or athletics. Those who are born naturally without the best genes are discriminated against and called Invalids.
Vincent is an Invalid who has always wanted to fly into outer space. He has the intellect and drive but not the flawless genes, therefore; he is incompetent. Vincent finds the opportunity to pose as a former swimmer, Jerome, who is injured in a car crash and no longer able to. Get Access. Good Essays. Read More. Better Essays. Exploring the Future Words 3 Pages. Exploring the Future. Gattaca: A Dystopian Society. Examples Of Utilitarianism In Gattaca. Satisfactory Essays.
Explore Wikis Community Central. Register Don't have an account? Valid and Invalid. Edit source History Talk 0. Meanings [ ] " Valid " means that the person was born in vitro and has been genetically modified in some way.
Easy Ways to tell if Someone is "Invalid [ ] There are other ways to tell if someone is invalid without doing a sample. Cancel Save. Universal Conquest Wiki.
0コメント